Maulana Wahiduddin Khan | Speaking Tree Website | Monday July 15, 2013Altaf Husain Hali (1873-1914) was fond of didactic poetry and considered it superior to all others. He reviewed classical Urdu poetry from this angle and found it wanting. It appeared to him to be full of pure exaggeration and fantasy, impossible tales of love and beauty, and fictitious flights of imagination.The people, who took pride in classical Urdu poetry and considered it a priceless heritage, did not take well of this criticism. They could not bear anybody calling their treasure trove worthless and they turned against him. They began publishing abusive and rude articles against the critic. In the face of this deluge, Hali adopted a policy of complete silence. Hence, Oudh "Punch' printed a sarcastic elegy. One of its stanzas ran "Our attacks cast a long shadow over Hali. He is devastated like the battlefield of Panipat."But all the accusations and the raging tempest remained totally one-sided. That is why Hali's opponents could not go on in this vein for long. After a while they grew silent. Somebody asked Hali: "What has silenced your enemies? It did no look as if they were ever going to be quite." In reply to this query Hali wrote a poem. One of its couplets "You ask, why have the critics grown silent. They said what they had to; we kept our peace."Only a serious objection or a scholarly criticism might be considered worth taking note of. If the criticism is sound, and further, if the argument is supported by a reasonable proof, then it should be accepted and the errors analysed.But if the opposition is mounted merely for its own sake, is bereft of scholarship and depth, is not based on facts but resorts to nit-picking and fault-finding, then the best reaction is silence. To try to answer such people is an exercise in futility and as useless as reading a sermon to a braying donkey. [Highlight1]
Related Articles
Article
The most delicate and dangerous part of space journeys is the point at which the spacecraft returns to the earth’s atmosphere. For instance, take the case of the Apollo-8 spacecraft. Before the capsule touched down on…
Article
Maulana Wahiduddin Khan | Teachings of IslamIf you happen to be in an open field when it starts to rain, you hasten to find shelter. This is not cowardice, this is realism. Similarly, when there is an earthquake, you…
Article
Maulana Wahiduddin Khan | Speaking Tree Website | February 13, 2017One day, a young man and his wife came to meet me. The man asked me for some advice. I replied, saying, "I will only say one thing: and that is,…
Article
Maulana Wahiduddin Khan | Speaking Tree Website | January 02, 2017 Complaining is a very deadly thing. It is the habit of complaining that is at the root of various social problems. When several people live together, it…
Article
Maulana Wahiduddin Khan | The Speaking Tree Website | January 04, 2016The Mughal prince, Aurangzeb, came into conflict with his father, Shahjahan, over certain political matters. He, therefore, dethroned Shahjahan and…
Article
Maulana Wahiduddin Khan | The Speaking Tree Website | December 07, 2015Mr. J. Krishnamurti was a well-known Indian thinker. When he used to go on a public stage, he would fold his hands and say, "Sir, I am a nobody," or…